Now Reading
Explainer: DA Boudin is Sending More Defendants to Diversion. Here’s What That Means
Wednesday, May 18, 2022

Explainer: DA Boudin is Sending More Defendants to Diversion. Here’s What That Means

District Attorney Chesa Boudin has made the city’s diversion courts a priority during his tenure, resolving more than 1,000 cases through diversion programs last year. The use of diversion has increased markedly: So far this year, 42% of cases resolved were resolved through diversion, compared to 18% in 2019, according to data published by the District Attorney. An alternative to jail custody and criminal convictions, diversion is intended as a form of rehabilitation for people arrested for low-level crimes. Many are oriented toward people suffering from mental or behavioral health disorders, as well as drug addiction and poverty. If a person successfully completes diversion, their criminal case is dismissed. 

Here, The Standard breaks down the city’s three main types of diversion programs, explaining what they do and who they are designed for.

What Is Collaborative Court?

Collaborative courts, run by San Francisco Superior Court, handle cases that have already been charged and require people to go to treatment or educational services in exchange for those charges being dropped. If the person convicted of a crime doesn’t comply with the program, then they are sent back through the regular criminal process. 

A judge makes the decision to admit someone into these programs.  

Examples of Collaborative Courts

Behavioral Health Court

People admitted into behavioral health court are required to participate in time-intensive classes and treatment. If the person is unhoused, then a case manager from Jail Psychiatric Services works to place them into housing. 

Clients must participate in the program for at least one year. If successful, they will have their case dismissed upon fulfillment of the program requirements, which are determined by a team of representatives from various agencies, including the public defender’s office, the district attorney’s office, Jail Behavioral Health and Reentry Services and the Adult Probation Department. 

Drug Court

Drug court is for people who are determined to be suffering solely from drug addiction without underlying mental conditions. This court focuses on teaching life skills and methods of dealing with trauma. Participants in this program submit to random drug tests and are required to remain arrest-free. Those in the outpatient treatment program, which requires sobriety for at least 45 consecutive days, are required to attend three recovery-oriented meetings per week.

Before a defendant has their charges dropped, they must test substance-free for 90 consecutive days. 

What Are Pre-Entry Programs?

Pre-entry programs are run by the district attorney’s office and allow a defendant to enter restorative justice services before they are charged with a crime.  

When a case comes to the district attorney’s office, and they decide that the defendant is a low-level offender or has little criminal history, they may send the defendant to a pre-entry program.

Examples of Pre-Entry Programs

Make It Right

The district attorney’s office introduced the Make It Right program in 2014 to create a dialogue between victims of crimes and their perpetrators. The program asks the victim what outcomes they would like to see from the person that harmed them. In violent cases, this could mean taking anger management classes or issuing a written statement of apology. In cases concerning theft, the program may require the offender to find a job before having their charges dropped. 

Neighborhood Courts

This court employs volunteer mediators from the neighborhood to hold low-level nonviolent offenders in misdemeanor cases accountable. Cases in this court may be resolved within weeks through discussions between the mediator, the victim and the defendant. 

What Is Statutory Diversion?

Statutory diversion programs are imposed by the state. Under a law enacted in January 2021, a superior court judge may send a defendant to one of the following diversion programs even if the prosecutor objects.  

See Also

Examples of Statutory Diversion Programs

Pretrial Diversion

The main type of state diversion program employed in San Francisco is a pretrial diversion, which is run by the San Francisco Pretrial Diversion Project, a nonprofit that has operated since the 1970s. Participants in this program may be required to complete a range of activities, including community service, counseling and educational programs, within a two-year span. 

The pretrial diversion program receives an average of 370 referrals per year, according to a 2020 report.

Mental Health Diversion

If a person is experiencing a diagnosable psychiatric condition, including an addiction severe enough to be a mental health disorder, a judge will grant them admittance into a mental health diversion court. In mental health diversion, defendants work with clinicians and receive individual assessments that guide a path to having charges dropped. Defendants are asked to report their own progress to the courts in this program. 

David Sjostedt can be reached at [email protected].
  • Thanks to the author for breaking down the details of the complexity of SF’s judicial system . It appears he public needs to learn a lot more about the process that we are living with. Who determines which court each person goes into? Is there a problem with that part of the program? The author has opened a new door of exploration for those who want to fix the system. Now we have some specific questions to ask. How many of these programs are based on state law and how many may be attributed to SF Ordinances? Thanks for pointing us in the right direction.

  • Thank you for this information regarding diversion programs in San Francisco.
    Can you provide success criteria and statistics for each program as a follow on report?

  • Patrick Thompson stabbed someone and then tried to throw him out a third story window. Chesa Boudin had him placed into “mental health diversion”. While in the mental health diversion program, Mr. Thompson skipped every one of his court dates. He was arrested for using drugs and attacked police officers with an axe. Based on that record, Chesa and the courts determined that Mr. Thompson had *successfully* completed his diversion program.

    Less than one year later, he stabbed two elderly Asian women who were waiting for the bus in an unprovoked attack.

    THAT is what diversion *really* means in Chesa Boudin’s San Francisco.

    https://abc7news.com/amp/patrick-thompson-san-francisco-ca-asian-stabbing-attack/10595207/

  • Approximately 30% of DUI defendants reoffend. Remember the 30% accounts for only those arrested by the police, consequently, the DUI reoffend rate is much-much higher.

    Diversion, in-effect, is a get out of jail and no-responsibility issue. A person that successfully completes diversion, which is easily accomplished, suffers no criminal consequences and is free to become a first time offender in a future crime. There is no limit to the amount of cases that a defendant could be granted diversion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.