Skip to main content
Community

Woman Sleeps as Tree Crashes Through Her Roof During Storm

Written by Olivia Cruz MayedaPublished Jan. 09, 2023 • 3:45pm
The aftermath of the felled tree at the Hutchinson residence in the foothills of Oakland on Monday, Jan. 9, 2023. | Olivia Cruz Mayeda/The Standard

English

Cindy Hutchinson woke up briefly to what she thought was an earthquake at 3 a.m. on Thursday. Later that morning, she rose from bed to discover that a tree had crashed through the roof of her dining room in the Oakland Hills.

Five days later, the rain is still pouring through the gaping hole in the house she’s lived in for 17 years.

All over the East Bay, fallen trees are a hazard for commuters, homeowners and pedestrians. Across California, trees knocked over during the recent storm number in the thousands.

Comcast employee Arturo Diaz stands outside 7000 Sayre Drive, where a felled tree lays on top of a house after it downed power lines and knocked out the internet in Oakland on Monday, Jan. 9, 2023. | Olivia Cruz Mayeda/The Standard

Hutchinson and her immediate neighbors haven’t had power for almost a week now. Still, she said she felt relatively lucky no one got hurt, as she stood in a large puddle of water and debris in her dining room on Monday.

East Bay Tree Service owner Victor Ghavamzadeh said the heavy rain last month followed by more heavy rain and high winds means trees are more prone to falling.

“I’ve been working since New Year’s nonstop,” Ghavamzadeh told The Standard.

The aftermath of the felled tree at the Hutchinson residence in the foothills of Oakland on Monday, Jan. 9, 2023 | Olivia Cruz Mayeda/The Standard

Heavy rain and high winds are the primary reasons trees have been falling over. While some assume lots of rain can only be good for the ecosystem, Bay Area ecologist Tea Parker-Essig says too much rain can prevent tree roots from getting the oxygen they need, leading to poor health and falling over. More broadly, though, the physics is just not in their favor during a bad storm.

“Trees are enormously heavy above ground,” Parker-Essig explained. “Given that we are on sloped terrain up here, roots can only handle these conditions for so long.”

English

Questions, comments or concerns about this article may be sent to [email protected]


Half Moon Bay Shooting: Consulates Reach Out to Families of Victims in China, Mexico

Half Moon Bay Shooting: Consulates Reach Out to Families of Victims in China, Mexico


SF’s Record-Breaking Olympic Sprinter Has Retired at the Age of 23

SF’s Record-Breaking Olympic Sprinter Has Retired at the Age of 23


White Supremacists Infiltrated Last Weekend’s Giant Anti-Abortion March

White Supremacists Infiltrated Last Weekend’s Giant Anti-Abortion March


Half Moon Bay Shootings: Mexican, Chinese Consulates Confirm Deaths

Half Moon Bay Shootings: Mexican, Chinese Consulates Confirm Deaths


One Dead, Seven Injured in Oakland Shooting

One Dead, Seven Injured in Oakland Shooting


Stay on top of what’s happening in your city

SF’s most important stories, delivered straight to your inbox



By clicking Subscribe you confirm you have read and agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge our Privacy Policy